Older Women writers – in demand or not?

Are older women writers in demand or are they ignored by the publishing industry? I read two articles recently which appear to offer opposite points of view on the subject of older women writers. One point of view is optimistic: 

… experts say: older writers are now at a premium – with radical, edgy women aged into their 80s particularly sought after. [Guardian 25.2.23]

The other suggests that the same old ageism/sexism is still operating against older women writers as it always has.

            … it seems many older women writers feel herded towards retirement before they’ve even got going. [Mslexia Dec/Jan/Feb 2022/23] 

I note that in the first quotation, the experts were from the perspective of publishers and agents. The second quotation reports the experience of the writers. Some of the difference I am questioning may arise from these contrasting perspectives. But which is it – older women writers are in demand or they are not?

Older Women Writers are in Demand

To support the argument that older women, especially women in their 80s, are the writers most sought after by publishers, Amelia Hill, writing in the Guardian, assembles the following evidence. First the publishers themselves are keen to publish work by older writers, apparently. It began with the small, independent presses, but now they are all at it.

“The publishing world is working hard to normalise and celebrate the vast diversity of women over 45 and to value their collected, distilled wisdom, their lifetime of reading and radicalism that is not possible for younger writers.”

This is the view of Lisa Highton, an agent and former publisher, quoted in the article.

Elizabeth Strout

Second, she lists several notable older writers, such as Bonnie Garmus, whose debut novel Lessons in Chemistry has been such a success. Others are Miranda Cowley Heller, Jo Browning Wroe, Louise Kennedy, Joanna Quinn Nikki May and Shelley Read.

Ann Tyler

And why are publishers taking on these books? The reason is simple – they are following the money.

“The vast majority of books are bought by women aged 45 and above. They’re a hugely important demographic and increasingly want to see themselves represented in books.” [Lisa Highton]

Women Writers are overlooked by Publishers

Mslexia has the strapline: the magazine for women who write. In an article from Mslexia (Dec/Jan/Feb 2022/23) by Debbie Taylor called The Time of our Lives, she explores the issues. I find it strange that Amelia Hill makes no reference to this article when she wrote the piece reported above. 

In her article Debbie Taylor describes how attitudes to age are defeating women writers, for example many literary prizes are age limited, which mitigates against older women because they often start their careers later and are more likely to have interrupted careers. No-one would want to quarrel with strategies to encourage young writers, but it is hard for older writers to gain success and exposure with so few literary awards open to them.

Barred from a raft of high-status awards, patronised or parodied in fiction and rendered literally invisible of book covers, no wonder women writers feel marginalised and wary of submitting their work. 

She quotes a survey where 50% of 1700 writers believed that ageism was a factor in how they were treated by agents and editors and 21% had experienced ageism. With those views in mind she went on to challenge three myths about older writers:

  • Their work is conventional and old-fashioned,
  • They have shorter writing careers,
  • Only old people want to read books by (or about) old people.

Although highly critical of Martin Amis and publishing practice that discriminates against older people, Debbie Taylor notices that there is some movement.

The doors are ajar for older writers. It’s up to us to ram our trainers, Doc Martens and stilettos into the gaps and push them open. True, ageism is an ongoing issue in publishing, but it’s not insurmountable – and let’s face it. This is a tough business whatever your age.

Helpfully for those wishing to do the necessary work, the article also listed sources, pressure groups and awards in a side bar. Bookword blog headed that list, and the article also featured a list of ten top titles from the older women in fiction list on this blog. This blog, and the series Older Women in Fiction, is mostly concerned with characters in novels and short stories. But it also promotes women writers, and older women writers.

Older Women Writers – in demand or not?

I think money, sometimes called the grey pound, will decide this issue. Succeeding generations of older women are better educated, get better jobs, have more disposable incomes, and live longer, all factors that will support buying books. We know they are the backbone of the book-buying readers. Publishers, agents, editors will not want to go against their own commercial interests.

So there may be sexism and ageism in publishing, but there are signs that this is changing. There is less reason to discriminate against older women writers than ever, especially as the quality of their writing matches that of younger writers. 

Related posts and articles

Things are definitely opening up’: the rise of older female writers by Amelia Hill in the Guardian; 25thFebruary 2023.

The Time of our Lives by Debbie Taylor, in Mslexia, Dec/Jan/February 2022/23. You can find the Mslexia website here.

Let’s have more Older Women Writers from Bookword February 2020, in which I reported on the opinions of some older women writers.

The Bookword page about the series older women in fiction can be found here. You can find more than 100 novels and collections of shorter fiction which feature older women. There are links to more than 60 books that I have reviewed on Bookword Blog.

10 Comments

Filed under Books, Feminism, Older women in fiction

10 Responses to Older Women writers – in demand or not?

  1. Interesting to make a similar argument about older male writers. The case would be very different, I think.

    • Caroline

      Men writers suffer from the same determination of publishers not to take risks, or to just carry on publishing the same old books. But they still get reviewed more, much more coverage in the press, and don’t suffer the indignity of bering referred to as ‘women’s fiction’.
      Thanks for the thought.
      Caroline

  2. Carole Jones

    Most of my favourite authors are women and many of them older – plus the ones who are dead!! … bur still adored. Current loves are Magda Szabo and Olga Tokarczuk.

    • Caroline

      Lots of good fiction from women, in translation and some of them are older. These are usually published by the independents, which is where some of the older women are gaining traction.
      Thanks for the comments.
      Caroline

  3. Interesting post, thank you. The main thing is to ensure equal opportunities for older writers (female and male) not preferential treatment. There certainly is ageism in publishing yet surely it is one area where the age of the writer is completely irrelevant if they can produce work people want to read.

    • Caroline

      I’d like to believe that the publishers are interested mainly in quality, but I think the larger publishers are mostly interested in what they know will sell, which means more of what they have sold before. Some publishers are pushing against that, mainly the independents. Readers can only buy the interesting looking books, but the publishers are often the gatekeepers and if they don’t pick up the quality writers because of prejudice, or lack of belief in older women writers then we don’t get to choose them. Perhaps that’s why we are seeing a rise in self-publishing as writers try to get their books out there.
      Caroline

  4. Interesting – Transita Press started up a couple of decades ago to publish books about older women by older women (middle-aged and above) but didn’t manage to sustain themselves, though they were also small without the marketing clout of a bigger publisher.

    • Caroline

      I don’t think I ever heard of them. Thanks for this information. Small sometimes works, we must remember.
      Caroline

  5. Hi Caroline,
    Fascinating article. I’d read the Guardian article by Amelia Hill soon after it was published and as an older woman writer, it came as very welcome news, although it was hard not to be somewhat sceptical. Hadn’t read the MsLexia article, although I’d love to. I’m writing an article myself on older women writers and as I don’t subscribe to MsLexia and it would cost me over $40 AUD to get a copy of that one issue mailed to me, I wondered if you might have a copy you were willing to send me, if it’s not too presumptuous to ask. I’d very much appreciate it.

    • Caroline

      Hi Anne,
      so pleased you found the Mslexia article interesting. I’m afraid I don’t have a spare copy of the article.
      I don’t know if a subscription is too much, but I would recommend Mslexia to any women writers.
      Sorry not to be able to help.
      Best wishes
      Caroline

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *