A New Genre?

Is there a new genre, the novel in which the middle-aged creative woman flees to a remote place to escape loss and finds herself, true love, redemption or some such. It’s probably a sub-genre. Whatever label we use here are three I have read. Two sent by my sister, which is kind of her. Perhaps she is concerned that I am a creative type, who has fled from all kinds of loss to a remote place. ‘Fled’ is not right and Devon is not that remote. I am not escaping loss, a broken heart or anything much at all, but I like the idea of the restorative power of the natural world.

143 Emot Geol

  1. Emotional Geology by Linda Gillard (2005)

Rose is suffering following the end of a very serious relationship with a climber, and suffers with intense depression. She is also a textiles artist. She seeks refuge from these demons on Uist (oh beautiful Outer Hebrides) and finds lovely neighbours and a damaged but highly desirable young man, also a climber, who challenges her withdrawal and eventually wins her over. It’s told from Rose’s point of view but also steps back to an authorial voice at times. I enjoyed the descriptions of Uist, which evoked the pleasures of the island as I experienced them.

143 Call

  1. Call of the Undertow by Linda Cracknell (2013)

Another story of a woman fleeing loss to work on her own in a lonely spot – this yime on the remote north eastern coast of Scotland. She experiences a gradual introduction to the community and reconnection with the world through nature. The sea birds are vivid in this novel.

In this story a boy Trothan is called by the undertow of the title. He is a gifted child, with powers of observation and map skills as well as a keen appreciation of the local folk ales. Maggie, a cartographer herself, encourages him as she works on her atlas of Nigeria. The boy is a keen observer of what goes on in the village but misjudges the community when he reveals the nefarious activities of his neighbours. He goes missing and one is led to believe he chose to join the seals in the sea. Maggie doesn’t find love, but she does find friendship and a place to feel at home, away from her past.

143 Still Life

  1. Still Life with Breadcrumbs by Anna Quindlen (2014)

Rebecca Winter, a photographer, is 60 and broke. He career has declined, her husband left her some time ago having destroyed her confidence, her mother was always a selfish woman. Rebecca moves to a cabin in upstate New York in an attempt to make ends meet and to consider her future. Of course life decides what this will be for her as she is adopted by the local tea shop owner, the roofer and a stray dog. She finds her way.

This is the familiar story of a sophisticated woman finding love with a younger and virile man. They rescue each other; he rescues her from the dissociation from life and she comforts him for life’s pains, including the death of a psychotic sister. It’s cleanly told, with nice strong characters and a story that rattles along.


Do you know any novels that take up the themes of these three?


A late addition, thanks to Deborah Smith on twitter.

143 Detour4. The Detour (or Ten White Geese in US) by Gerbrand Bakker (2012), translated from the Dutch by David Colmar.

The best of them all and not romantic fiction but a bleak story of a woman’s life falling apart, despite seeking escape in remote Wales. Very absorbing, interesting style and shortlisted for IMPAC prize. (See also The Twin by the same author, different themes.)

There’s something about those celtic remotenesses!

You can subscribe and receive email notifications of future blogposts by entering your email address in the box at the top of the column on the right.


Filed under Books, Reading, Reviews

7 Responses to A New Genre?

  1. Anne

    I can’t wait to read these – I hope they don’t give me any ideas! Not bothered about the young virile lover (a companionable dog would do) but a bit of peace and quiet would be nice…….

    • Caroline

      Hi Anne, I think that must be Christmas busyness coming through here in your comment. See my late addition for a more bracing read.

  2. They all sound like lovely escapist, romantic novels. Which chapter in your book should they have read before making their exit? 🙂

    • Caroline

      Thanks Norah, but see my late addition to the genre, not romantic or escapist.
      And they were all too creative to do anything like retire!

  3. Anne

    Just downloaded The Detour ( that’s where the Kindle really scores I must say) so I will let you know what I think.

  4. Anne

    I could not put “The Detour” down. I really really enjoyed it. It had a bit of everything- first a very realistic sense of place- her cottage and its grounds were described in great detail and so I could picture her in the cottage, enjoying the seclusion and remoteness but what is so clever is that as you read you pick up a suspicion of unease. This grows and the author keeps giving the reader a little bit more information- why is she taking paracetamol so regularly- reference to strange pains and smells- I will try not to give the plot away- and then the book -which has been moving on at a gentle pace- suddenly picks up speed and we meet- the husband, the parents, the boy……..until it hurtles to its end! Marvellous!
    This is a clever and controlled piece of writing but it is not obscure- it is easy to read and fully engaging. I shall try “The Twin” sometime.

    • Caroline

      Glad you enjoyed this one Anne. I look orward to reading your comments on The Twin, which I thought was even more brilliant. C xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *